Curry Chicken – Caribbean Style with Coconut Milk

Curry Chicken – Caribbean Style with Coconut Milk

Curry Chicken Is My Favorite

One of my favorite meals is Curry Chicken. I love all types of curry dishes. As you may be aware curry tastes different everywhere you go. I have had Indian curries, Asian curry, West Indian or Caribbean curry. Within those cultures there are sub cultures that make curry differently. For example, our family has best friends that are Guyanese, so I have always known that West Indian curry tastes different than Jamaican curry. Thai curry tastes completely different than Filipino curry dishes I’ve had. Filipino curry is influenced a lot by Indonesian culture, which is influenced by Indian flavors. Well, all curry is influenced by Indian curry.

My mom always made a version of curry chicken that is extremely delicious. I want to say my mom’s chicken curry is more Caribbean than anything, but because we are a multicultural family I want to say that she uses Asian influence in her curry at times as well. To be honest, my mom will make a version that is different than the last because she uses what we have on hand. The way she taught me to make a curry dish might be sacrilegious to any of the cultures that are known for curry.

Coconut Milk in Curry Chicken?

I will eat any curry, but if I had to choose I think I like Caribbean curries the best. I also prefer curry chicken with coconut milk. My Guyanese and Trinidadian friends may frown upon it, but the coconut milk makes the curry rich and creamy. It’s perfect over rice. Hey, I like roti too, but at home I eat my curry with rice. One of these days I’ll share a Curry Goat tutorial. That recipe uses no coconut milk. Red meat curries are better without coconut milk. Coconut milk seems to go better with chicken, fish or any other seafood.

Switch It Up

I experiment with different curry powder brands. My mother went to Jamaica and brought home EasiSpice curry, which she says is a favorite on the island. She also goes to the West Indian grocery and buys Chief brand curry and masala. We almost always use Chief brand when making Curry Goat, but I’ve used it for chicken and it’s just fine. When we get Indian curry my mom usually sticks to garam masala and she always gets different brands. There are so many different styles of curry powder based on the type of dish.

You can also use whatever veggies you like, or none at all. Peas and carrots are what my mom usually threw in, so that’s my favorite vegetable combination to put in curry chicken. She has also made it with Bell Peppers (green and red). You will rarely see West Indian curry with veggies in it. I know my mom grew up eating Pinoy style curries. Filipinos like putting different vegetables in curry dishes and the peas and carrots influence comes from golden beef curry dishes.

I always like my curry with onions and potatoes, however, when my mom went low-carb on a Keto diet she cut the potatoes out and she ate it without rice. You can do the same if you have low carb diet restrictions.


In the video tutorial I actually show 3 different types of curry powder that I had on hand when I list out the ingredients, but I only used one (EasiSpice). I also used EasiSpice chicken seasoning. Since I had this seasoning I didn’t have to use a lot of the spices that I would normally put in separately.

I also want to note that I used boneless chicken. My mom prefers to cook with bone in chicken. She says that bones make the “broth” tastier. It’s true, but you have to add a little more cooking time when you have anything bone in. My dad and I prefer no bones, well, just because it’s easier to eat faster! Also note that I’m using chicken thighs witch is dark meat. My mom will sometimes cut up a whole chicken, but if she buys a pack of chicken she prefers all dark. She says dark meat is healthier for you, contrary to popular belief and it tastes better. If you prefer white meat try not to overcook as it gets dry fast. Honestly, with curry, your meat is always flavorful so it’s hard to go wrong with overcooking…unless you burn it.

Another note: People from the Islands always wash their chicken in citrus like lime juice, lemon juice and/or vinegar. There are different schools of thought on whether or not it is needed. We always keep a large bottle of Florida Key West Key Lime Juice in our refrigerator for marinating, adding flavor to chicken, fish and pasta dishes, but we also use it to clean our meats.

Make This Chicken Curry Dinner Tonight!

Once I learned how to make this dish, I’m the only one in the house that cooks curry while my mom and dad (and sisters) relax. The family says I’m the “curry master.” Well, try the recipe and you be the judge.

Coconut Curry Chicken

A delicious and easy to make caribbean coconut curry chicken dish!
Prep Time5 mins
Cook Time20 mins
Total Time25 mins
Course: Main Course
Cuisine: Caribbean, West Indian, Jamaican, Indian
Keyword: Curry Chicken


  • 1-2 Pounds Boneless Chicken Thighs Add an extra 10 minutes to cook time for bone in thighs
  • 2 tbsp Curry Powder
  • 1 medium-large Onion
  • 3 medium Potatoes
  • 1 13.5 Oz Can Coconut Milk
  • 1 tbsp Garlic Powder Omit if have Caribbean Chicken Seasoning
  • 1 tbsp Allspice Omit if have Caribbean Chicken Seasoning
  • 1 tbsp Onion Powder Omit if have Caribbean Chicken Seasoning
  • 1 tbsp Thyme
  • 1 tsp Black Pepper Omit if have Caribbean Chicken Seasoning
  • 1 tsp White Pepper Omit if have Caribbean Chicken Seasoning
  • 1-3 tsp Cayenne Pepper or 1 Scotch Bonnett Pepper Optional (For Spicy Curry)
  • 1 1/2 cup Florida Key West Key Lime Juice can use lemon juice or vinegar for washing chicken
  • 3 tbsp Oil (grapeseed, coconut oil or ghee)
  • 10 oz package of frozen peas and carrots


  • Empty chicken into a bowl and pour Florida Key West Key Lime Juice over the chicken. Ensure all of the chicken is coated in the key lime juice and fill the bowl with water. Move the chicken around in the water lime mixture then pour the water out and rinse the chicken with clean cold water. Now your chicken is clean and ready for seasoning.
  • Sprinkle all of the spices (not the curry) onto the chicken ensuring that the seasoning mixture is rubbed into the chicken well. Put the chicken aside as you prep the potatoes and onions.
  • Cut potatoes into bite sized cubes and put aside.
  • Rough chop your onion.
  • Add the oil coating the bottom of your pot.
  • Turn the stove on to medium high heat.
  • Add Curry Powder to pot and mix into the oil until simmering.
  • Add chicken pieces to the pot and wait 2 minutes. Flip the chicken and wait another 2 minutes.
  • Add onions and stir ensuring the onions are covered in curry.
  • Add 1 cup of water.
  • Add the potatoes and stir ensuring the potatoes are covered in curry.
  • Cover the pot and turn the heat down to medium low. Wait 5 minutes.
  • Add coconut milk stir, cover the pot. Wait 5 minutes.
  • Check the potatoes to ensure they are tender. If they are not tender give it more time to simmer.
  • Once the potatoes are tender you will notice that your curry sauce has also thickened.
  • Add the frozen peas and carrots to the pot and stir. The entire dish is done once the peas and carrots are warmed through, about 2-5 minutes depending on how frozen the veggies are. Turn off the heat and serve over rice.
    Chicken Curry in a Pot


4 thoughts on “Curry Chicken – Caribbean Style with Coconut Milk”

  • I saw the title and I thought this recipe sounds really interesting.  I was right!  When I make it, it will definitely be the spicier curry chicken. My husband loves spicy, spicier the better.   Thanks for sharing this great recipe!  I usually use chicken breasts because I thought they were healthier. Are the thighs really healthier??  We don’t eat potatoes, so I’ll probably use cauliflower and maybe put some broccoli in, too. 

    • Hi Lynn,

      For heat, to be authentic to the Caribbean you can use fresh scotch bonnet or habanero peppers. However hot curry powder or adding cayenne red pepper powder to your favorite curry powder works very to spice things up!

      As for white vs dark meat: There was a popular Dr. Oz show that discussed how we’ve had it all wrong with dark and white meat. Chickens don’t fly (at least not that far) so their legs and thighs are the only body parts that get exercise. Birds that fly, like Duck are all dark meat and healthier. Dark meat is more dense in nutrients, has more iron and it tastes better! White breast meat on chickens don’t get a lot of exercise and does not contain as much iron and nutrients as dark meat. Here’s the video to the Dr. Oz episode:

      Also, when my family goes low-carb we will use turnips instead of potato! It actually gives the curry a different zing. Turnips work well in beef stew in place of potatoes too. We also use fresh carrots and cut them bigger when going low carb just to get bigger chunks, especially if we don’t have turnips. We still use frozen peas! 

      So glad you’re trying the recipe. 

      Thanks for reading my blog!

  • Hello NelSazon, thanks for sharing this post. Immediately I saw the headline, I got interested in the post and I’m glad I was not disappointed at all. I’m a curry devourer and just like you, I prefer the Caribbean curry a lot better. I like the looks of this recipe and its mouthwatering here. I cannot wait to have my share of this by making it to surprise my wife. I will be back here to give feedbacks after I have tried making it too following the process highlighted above. Thanks for sharing this mouth watering pictures… I mean write up😜

    • Wow thanks Mr. RoDarrick! I  It’s a pretty easy recipe as is and you can modify it with different add ins! If I don’t have peas and carrots I will sometimes chop up colorful bell peppers and throw that in. Curry is so versatile! Thanks for reading my blog post I hope you and your wife enjoy the curry chicken! Looking forward to hearing how it turned out!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *